|
Post by Noland Hardy on May 7, 2018 1:08:21 GMT -5
Ok so Noland can counter the effect of freeze enemy because he has negated the effect of battle gear once and according to the rule the effect of gate card, bakugan trap, battle gear can be negated/cancelled/reflected, etc only once, so as he have only negated batter gear effect noland can still negate/cancel/reflect the gate card. I got excited for a second... This doesn't make much sense, but you were very close, and then you took several steps backwards at the same time. I'll say two things about this submission. 1. Your interpretation of that rule is incorrect, and you know it is. You were correct about it before you changed it. 2. I like how you changed it from "can't" to "can".
|
|
|
Post by kuro on May 7, 2018 1:27:09 GMT -5
Modified again.
|
|
|
Post by Noland Hardy on May 7, 2018 1:32:55 GMT -5
Noland cannot counter the effect of freeze enemy because rules states that the countering limit of bakugan trap effect, battle gear effect, gate card effect, etc is only 1, which means one can only negate/cancel/reflect, etc. one of the effects. As noland already have negated the effect of battle gear he cannot negate/cancel/reflect the effect of freeze enemy as it is an gate card. ...Now I'm getting concerned. I'm guessing the second thing I told you on my previous post was invisible.
|
|
|
Post by Blaze Hayes on May 7, 2018 8:08:51 GMT -5
Right. Let me give it a go. So what we have is Noland already used his a counter limitation on the battle gear effect and therefore cannot use that limitation again to counter the gate card that way. If Noland has a battle gear out that has a counter effect he could use that. But with there being no mention of Noland having a battle gear out etc we can assume he has not got one making this possibility a no. On top of this as far as we know he has no used his special counter limitation as it has not been mentioned about him using it, therefore he could also use protection to stop the effect as it does effect him. So my answer is yes he could because of protection.
|
|
|
Post by uselessloserinfinty on May 7, 2018 8:24:27 GMT -5
modified
|
|
|
Module 1
May 7, 2018 12:45:02 GMT -5
via mobile
Post by Allen Silva on May 7, 2018 12:45:02 GMT -5
Noland has at least 3 ways i can think of to counter Freeze enemy. He could use a special ability to switch the gate or he could gain protection. A catch all effect negation would also work, as it isnt specifically targeting the gate effect it would bypass the limit issue.
|
|
|
Post by Zeno on May 7, 2018 14:14:56 GMT -5
Right. Let me give it a go. So what we have is Noland already used his a counter limitation on the battle gear effect and therefore cannot use that limitation again to counter the gate card that way. If Noland has a battle gear out that has a counter effect he could use that. But with there being no mention of Noland having a battle gear out etc we can assume he has not got one making this possibility a no. On top of this as far as we know he has no used his special counter limitation as it has not been mentioned about him using it, therefore he could also use protection to stop the effect as it does effect him. So my answer is yes he could because of protection. Noland has at least 3 ways i can think of to counter Freeze enemy. He could use a special ability to switch the gate or he could gain protection. A catch all effect negation would also work, as it isnt specifically targeting the gate effect it would bypass the limit issue. And with that, I won't be accepting anymore submissions. ^_^
|
|
|
Post by Noland Hardy on May 7, 2018 14:46:13 GMT -5
As Damian, which is also me, has hinted towards, a winning submission has finally been made, and no modifications were made to the post either. ^_^ Now...the winner of Module 1 is........ Right. Let me give it a go. So what we have is Noland already used his a counter limitation on the battle gear effect and therefore cannot use that limitation again to counter the gate card that way. If Noland has a battle gear out that has a counter effect he could use that. But with there being no mention of Noland having a battle gear out etc we can assume he has not got one making this possibility a no. On top of this as far as we know he has no used his special counter limitation as it has not been mentioned about him using it, therefore he could also use protection to stop the effect as it does effect him. So my answer is yes he could because of protection. Blaze!!!!! She had exactly what I was looking for. As she explained, Noland negating Dan's Battle Gear has deprived him of the limit to be able to do the same to Freeze Enemy; however, since there is a limit of special counter such as protection and absorption, Noland will be able to use that limit in order to respond to the gate card if he wished. --- Allen's post is also good, but his submission gets some points off because of the last thing he said. He said a negation that doesn't discriminate will mean that Noland will not use the limitation of negating the Gate Card, and that simply isn't true. If the said item is negated from playing the effect, it will count towards the limits.
Blaze will now be rewarded with 500 Honor Points and one of Seiki's cards, Sylphystia. Allen, you did get the right answer, so I'm going to give you 500 Honor Points as well, but I'm going to choose for you to receive your own card, Goliath Fortress. This will be the format of all modules going forward. It's educational, and it can also get you some nice loot in the event you get it right. Hopefully, you can learn from this module and apply it to some of your battles. Until next time.
|
|